Monday, September 08, 2008

Texas Statewide Historical Maps & Positional Accuracy Pt. 1

We have been undertaking a project, called the Texas Time Machine (TTM), which requires us to georeference statewide historic maps of Texas.

Brief overview of TTM:
Preparing historical materials for use within GIS for geographic analysis requires a large time commitment and high level of expertise. Once prepared, the researcher still needs to understand the fundamentals of operating a large desktop GIS application. TTM resolves this by (1) compiling a collection of prepared historic materials, and (2) enabling interaction with these materials within Google Maps and Google Earth (as well as desktop GIS applications).

TTM provides 4 ways to view geographically referenced maps, statistics, and images. (1) Via Google Map overlays, (2) Via downloadable Google Earth KMZ files, (3) Via downloadable GIS Data, and (4) Via downloadable un-georeferenced images.
I want to focus this post specifically on how we are georeferencing 150 year old maps whose geography encompasses over 250,000 square miles.

Georeference Scanned Map Image
  1. The intended coordinate system of the original cartographer needs to be determined. In consultation with our Cartographic Archivist Librarian, we discovered that for the majority of the maps dating int he 19th century a Mercator system was intended.
  2. Control points need to be used for georeferencing. For the first order, we use control points from the state outline, namely the Pan Handle, westernmost tip, easternmost tip, and southernmost tip. Then, we overlay a uniform 5x5 grid shapefile (25 standard polygon features) over the ungeoreferenced image within ArcMap. One city per cell is used as a control point. Cells without cities indicated on the scanned map will not contain control points.
NSSDA & Historical Measurements
We are adhering to the National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy (NSSDA). The two primary resources we followed are:
  • ‘Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards, Part 3: National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy’
  • ‘Positional Accuracy Handbook: Using the National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy to measure and report geographic data quality’.
Both resources can be accessed here.

The first work above provides a general overview of the process and specific case studies where one can learn by those examples. There are two cases for measuring horizontal accuracy.
  • The first case is on page 3-10. This case demonstrates how to calculate error with 95% confidence when the x-axis error is equal to the y-error. RMSE(x) == RMSE(y). (Root Mean Square Error) I do not anticipate this as applicable as our maps are not consistently drawn to scale.
  • The second case is on page 3-11. This case is entitled ‘Approximating Circular Standard Error When RMSE(x) != RSME(y)’. However, the details of the case demonstrate how to calculate error when RMSE(min)/RMSE(max) is between 0.6 and 1.0. This implies an almost consistent error across the x- and y-axis.
    • The formula provided is: Accuracy ~ 2.4477 * 0.5 * (RMSE(x) + RMSE(y)). This is in effect the average of the two errors (added and divided by 2) and then multiplied by the full circle confidence of 95% as designated by the ‘Generalized Circular Probable Error’ table. (JSTOR access, page #170).
    • This case continues to explain that the circular standard error at 39.35% confidence may be approximated at 0.5 * (RMSE(x) + RMSE(y)).
    • The big question for us is how can these numbers be adjusted to accommodate where RMSE(min)/RMSE(max) is less than 0.6.
  • The second work above is a handbook/workbook that enables the easy use of the first case specified in the first work. Namely, where RMSE(x) == RMSE(y). As stated above, this is not the case with our maps because cartographers could not draw them to scale 150 years ago. However, this second work provides print and downloadable versions of a spreadsheet that modified for our uses, namely adjusting the modifier at the end based on the RMSE ratio.
  • Both works provide template language to include in the GIS metadata, as well as specific metadata fields where positional accuracy should be reported.
Our Geographic Accuracy Measurement Procedures
  • Ha! I am tired of writing at the moment and will lay out out specific in-house procedures tomorrow. I will also include some snippets from one of our metadata records.

33 comments:

Web Hosting Delhi said...

Thank you for this great post.

Dissertation Help said...

Nice, accurate and to the point. Not everyone can provide information with proper flow. Good post. I am going to save the URL and will definitely visit again. Keep it up.
----------------------------------------------
Dissertation Help | Custom Dissertation

Viko said...

Good post and a fantastic read. You have raised some valid points. Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer.
Assisted Suicide essays || Euthanasia essays

Junaid Ahmed said...

i get lots of interesting information from here

Nokia Applications | Nokia Games | Nokia Themes | Nokia Prices | Nokia Reviews

onwebmedia said...

Personally, the post is in fact the most excellent on this impressive topic. I harmonize with your conclusions and will keenly look further to your future updates.
assault lawyer Fort Worth

generic viagra online said...

Wow, nice post,there are many person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post

dominos coupons said...

This is one of the best websites that i have ever found.. lots of useful information here. Thanks and cheers mate.

dominos coupons

Alex Mick said...

i use social networking and try to provide people with quality content.
Classic Cardy

Alex Mick said...

It gives me excellent enjoyment to look at your website and delight in your excellent content here. I like it. I know you put a lot of awareness to these content, each of them is practical and is very useful! 
Glasgow accommodation
Glasgow bed and breakfast

Anonymous said...

Good Morning Children Ltd was first thought of in February 2006 with the company being launched in April 2006, closely followed by the website launch in Semptember 2006.  It is run by Mike and Chrissie who have about 50 years of teaching experience between them, plus five academic years of providing our resources to the primary education market.  Our rapidly expanding business has led to thousands of classes in the UK and beyond regularly using our resources.
Creative Thinking Skills
Primary Teaching Resources
Thinking and Reasoning

romancito2010 said...

Great site and amazing article, thanks for all the information.

Cataratas en los ojos

Alex Mick said...

Which a great site to cease and watch by, I admire your weblog and really like to leave a comment right
here!!! Thanks for the nice publish.
floor clocks

Unknown said...

ipod touch apps said...

"This is a very good tips especially to those new to blogosphere, brief and accurate information… Thanks for sharing this one. A must read article."

Alex Mick said...

You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses taking time and real effort to make a good article !!
Aberdeen bed and breakfast

Alis Stafford said...

You must have done good research for the work; I appreciate your efforts.
Show Plates

Alex Mick said...

Important blog having interested information. Few times we ignore this sort of things & also suffer a lot as well. How ever we all can save a lot with the assistance of these all tips.
commercial painting

dissertation writing said...

amazing research about Texas Statewide Historical Maps,and I Thankful for your post writing efforts

literature review help said...

For whatever reason the form text specifying the three procedure steps (that alternated while processing to inform the user which step was currently operating) were not appearing in ArcGIS 9.2. This resulted in the appearance that nothing was happening.

BA Dissertation said...

Thank you for this post, we are a online dating website blog network,

dissertation structure said...

understand the fundamentals of operating very difficult task for the researcher,but is possible


ampoule led e14 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
ampoule led e14 said...

This is one of the best websites that i have ever found.. Informative and worth-full info share here. Thanks ..

ampoule led e14

Unknown said...

This is really what I was searching for. I am feeling joyful to came here.I would like to thank you for sharing such info with us,I like to advise you that Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well.

Counter Strike 1.6

descargar whatsapp plus gratis said...

I had to Indo open new cafe descargar whatsapp plus gratis fast , use app baixar whatsapp plus very comfortable , play descargar mobogenie games hot descargar whatsapp plus gratis , baixar whatsapp plus , descargar mobogenie

yoob games said...

This article seems to be overlooking the fact that information is a saleable commodity and altruism comes a poor second to commerce, especially in the health field. Genetic research may be a totally fascinating pursuit for those involved but will it truly provide any realistic benefits?
yoob games | yoob | Juegos de friv yoob | Yoob |
This is an amazing charming space. Beautifully done. I had the opportunity to intern with Liz and she is absolutely incredible! I love all of her work!

Unknown said...

I feel very loved it and I'm happy about this. Thank you for sharing.
earn to die
earn to die 2
earn to die 3
earn to die 4
earn to die 2012
earn to die 1
earn to die part 2
earn to die 6

Unknown said...

All the best blogs that is very useful for keeping me share the ideas
of the future as well this is really what I was looking for, and I am
very happy to come here. Thank you very much
earn to die 3
game hot earn to die 3
Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give youu a shout out from Austin Texas! Just wanted to tell you keep up the fantastic work!my weblog
game hot tank trouble 3
game tank trouble

alicetaylor said...

The article you have shared here very awesome. I really like and appreciated your work. I read deeply your article, the points you have mentioned in this article are useful

run 3 | monkey go happy |  atari breakout |

outstanding essay help said...

wonderful,
essay writer
essay writers
essay writing services
custom essay writer
essay help

Max said...

Very well written and informative post I love it.

Unknown said...

https://coolmathgames.com Web gaming offers a few classifications/genres for players to look over and choose wisely. Some offer virtual economies where players can produce, purchase and offer virtual products, much like in this present reality.
https://coolmathgamesz.com

TrCodex said...

Super Smash Flash 4 , the new version of Super Smash Flash 4 is now with you! The graphics of the game are much improved and more successful than previous versions. Super Smash Flash 4 is waiting for you to have fun.

yanmaneee said...

yeezy boost 350
lebron shoes
jordan 6
giannis antetokounmpo shoes
off white shoes
yeezy sneakers
off white jordan 1
yeezy supply
supreme clothing
longchamp